05. tbl. 99. árg. 2013

Experience of Icelandic adults of corporal punishment and abuse in childhood

Reynsla fullorðinna Íslendinga af líkamlegum refsingum og ofbeldi í æsku

Introduction: Corporal punishment and abuse of children can have a negative impact on their health and well-being. The aim is to examine on Icelandic adults, experience of corporal punishment as children, its prevalence, justification as victims, and its impact on the assessment of their upbringing.

Materials and methods: From the national population register, out of 1500 randomly selected adults 18 years and older, 977 (65%) partici-pated. In a telephone interview, they appraised their upbringing, fol-l-owed by questions regarding 5 specific forms of corporal punishment in addition to an open-ended question about other forms experienced.

Results: Out of 968 respondents, 810 (84%) regarded their upbringing as good. In total, 465 (48%) reported at least one form of corporal punishment in childhood, with spanking being the most prevalent one (29%). Respondents 30 years and older were 1.9 times more likely to have experienced corporal punishment compared to those who were younger (95% CI 1.4-2.6) and males were 1.6 times more likely to report it compared to females (95% CI 1.2-2.0). Those who had frequently been punished were significantly more likely to hold of the opinion that it had never been justified (OR=6.5; 95% CI 1.8-22.9) and were more likely to judge their upbringing to have been reasonable or bad (OR=10.2; 95% CI 4.7-21.9) compared to those who had no such experience.

Conclusion: The practice of corporal punishment of Icelandic children was significantly less prevalent among respondents born about 1980 and later compared to those born earlier. Increased public debate and awareness of children´s rights and changed ideas about their upbringing has facilitated such development.

1Directorate of Health and Reykjavík University, 2Faculty of Social and Human Sciences, University of Iceland.

Table I. Demographic background of participants.

                                   N n (%)

Sex

            Male

            Female

977

 

471 (48)

506 (52)

Age (years)

            18-29

            30-39

            40-49

            50-59

            60-

977

 

 

214 (22)

160 (17)

172 (18)

199 (20)

232 (23)

Place of living

            Greater Reykjavík capital area

            Elsewhere in Iceland

977

 

599 (61)

378 (39)

Education

            Compulsory primary and lower secondary

            Upper secondary

            University

964

 

276 (29)

355 (37)

333 (34)

Civil status

            Married

            Cohabitation

            Single

            Divorced

            Widow/-er

959

 

506 (53)

189 (20)

195 (20)

33 (3)

36 (4)

Income (in 1000 ISK)*

            <150

            150-299

            300-549

            550-

792

 

174 (22)

219 (28)

306 (38)

93 (12)

* At the time of survey, 1 euro=155 ISK; 1 US$=112 ISK

 

Table II.    Proportion of participants with experience of corporal punishment as children.

  Answered yes, %
Younger than 30 years (n=110) 36
30-49 years (n=329) 49
50-69 years (n=328) 53
70+ years and older (n=98) 52

 

 

Table III. Participants´experience of different forms of physical punishment.

    n (%)

 

Form of corporal punishment

 

N

 

Never

 

Once

Several times Often or very often
Spanking 959 679 (71) 124 (13) 134 (14) 22 (2)
Slapping on the cheek 962 822 (85) 77 (8) 53 (6) 10 (1)
Shaking 952 812 (85) 20 (2) 110 (12) 10 (1)
Slapping on the fingers 949 830 (88) 18 (2) 91 (9) 10 (1)
Ear pulling and twisting 961 935 (97) 6 (1) 14 (1) 6 (1)
Other 960 933 (97) 4 (1) 14 (1) 9 (1)

 


Table IV.        Participants´ judgement on their upbringing by experience of different forms of corporal punishment. 

 

Experience of different forms of corporal punishment

% (n)

 
 

None

 

One form Two forms Three or more forms

Mean of forms experienced

(95% CI)

Respondents who judged their upbringing as good 58 (458) 28 (237) 10 (82) 4 (29) 0,61 (0,56-0,67)
Respondents who judged their upbringing as reasonable 31 (43) 28 (38) 28 (38) 13 (20) 1,34 (1,13-1,55)
Respondents who judged their upbringing as bad 17 (3) 17 (3) 22 (4) 44 (7) 2,47 (1,46-3,49)

 



Þetta vefsvæði byggir á Eplica